D25.1 Acid Strength and Molecular Structure

Acid-base reactions, like many other chemical reactions, involve breaking and forming bonds. Hence, we can use our chemical understanding of molecular structure and stability to understand what makes some acids stronger than others.

We know that an equilibrium favors the thermodynamically more stable side of the reaction, and that the magnitude of the equilibrium constant reflects the energy difference (ΔrG°) between the reactants and products. Consequently, for an acid-base equilibrium:

HA(aq) + H2O(ℓ) ⇌ A(aq) + H3O+(aq)

anything that stabilizes A relative to HA, or destabilizes HA relative to A, will make ΔrG° more negative, increasing Ka, and hence make HA a stronger acid. Similarly, anything that stabilizes HA relative to A, or desabilizes A relative to HA, will make ΔrG° more positive, decreasing Ka, and hence make HA a weaker acid. This idea is illustrated pictorially below.

Figure: thermodynamics of acid-base reactions. Acid strength is dependent on the thermodynamics of the acid-base reaction. The relative stability of HA and A influences the ΔrG° of the reaction and hence the Ka of the acid.

In other words, a strong acid is a molecule that is higher in energy (less stable) than its conjugate base. This instability relative to its conjugate base drives its reactivity in an acid-base reaction, making it a strong acid. Similarly, a weak acid is a molecule that is lower in energy (more stable) than its conjugate base. This relative stability makes it less reactive in an acid-base reaction, making it a weak acid.

The same thermodynamic reasonings apply when considering the basicity of a generic base A in the equilibrium:

A(aq) + H2O(ℓ) ⇌ HA(aq) + OH(aq)

So how do we think about what stabilizes, or destabilizes, a molecule? There are a few factors to consider.

Bond Strength

In general, a stronger H–A bond corresponds to a more stable HA molecule, which leads to a less acidic HA.

This effect is illustrated by the hydrogen halide series [HX(aq) + H2O(ℓ) ⇌ X(aq) + H3O+(aq)]:

HF HCl HBr HI
Average Bond Enthalpy (kJ/mol) 566 431 366 299
ΔrG° (kJ/mol, 25 °C) +18 −35 −51 −53
Ka (25 °C) 6.8 × 10−4 1.2 × 106 7.9 × 108 2 × 109

Note that the “average bond enthalpy” values listed above are associated with a different bond breaking reaction than acid-base reactions. Specifically, a hydrogen atom is produced instead of a hydrogen ion:

HX(g) ⟶ X·(g) + H·(g)

Nonetheless, these values can be used to estimate the bond strengths. In the hydrogen halide series, the overlap between the H 1s orbital and the halogen atom (X) valence orbital decreases as you go down the periodic group, leading to weaker H-X covalent bonds as reflected by their average bond enthalpy values. If a HX molecule is held together by a weaker bond, then the molecule itselft is less stable. Therefore, as you go from HF to HI, the HX bond is weaker, the HX molecule is less stable, and HX is more acidic.

A similar trend is observed going down other groups. For example, for group 16 [H2Y(aq) + H2O(ℓ) ⇌ HY(aq) + H3O+(aq)]:

H2O H2S H2Se H2Te
Average Bond Enthalpy (kJ/mol) 467 347 276 238
ΔrG° (kJ/mol, 25 °C) +80 +40 +22 +15
Ka (25 °C) 1.0 × 10−14 1.0 × 10-7 1.3 × 10-4 2.5 × 10-3

Electronegativity of the atom where the excess electron resides

Often, the conjugate base of an acid is negatively charged. For these molecules, factors that stabilize the excess electron would stabilize the conjugate base, and thereby favor the dissociation of the acid and make it a stronger acid. One of these factors is the electonegativity of the atom where the excess electron resides.

For an example, consider the relative acidity of the following acids [HnZ(aq) + H2O(ℓ) ⇌ Hn-1Z(aq) + H3O+(aq)]:

Acid (HnZ) CH4 NH3 H2O HF
Conjugate base (Hn-1Z) CH3 NH2 OH F
ΔrG° (kJ/mol, 25 °C) +300 +200 +80 +18
Ka (25 °C) 1 × 10−50 1 × 10-36 1.0 × 10-14 6.8 × 10−4

In all four of these conjugate bases, the excess electron resides mostly on the second row element (C, N, O, or F), where the electronegativity trend is F > O > N > C. The excess electron (which gives rise to the -1 charge) is at a lower energy (more stable) when it resides on a more electronegative atom. Therefore, F can stabilize the extra electron better than OH, which is in turn better than NH2, which is better than CH3. Consequently, HF can dissociate and form H+ and F to a greater extent compared to H2O can form H+ and OH, and so forth. And this is increasing acid strength from CH4 to HF is indeed the trend we see in the table above.

The same trend is predicted by analyzing the acids: as the electronegativity of Z in HnZ increases, the Z–H bond becomes more polar (with greater δ on Z and greater δ+ on H), thus favoring dissociation to form Hn-1Z and H+. (Note that this difference in bond polarity does not inform on bond strength differences. The average bond enthalpies (kJ/mol) are: C-H (416), N-H (391), O-H (467), F-H (566).)

Due to both the increasing stability of the conjugate base and the increasing polarization of the Z–H bond in the acid, acid strengths of binary hydrides generally increase as we go from left to right across a row of the periodic table.

Electron Delocalization

Let us consider two types of compounds, carboxylic acids (RCOOH) and alcohols (ROH), acting as an acid in an acid-base reaction. For both species, an O-H bond is broken during the acid-base reaction. For example, at 25 °C,

While acetic acids are not strong acids (Ka is <1), they nonetheless are stronger acids than alcohols by 10,000,000,000 times. Why should the presence of a carbonyl group adjacent to a hydroxyl group have such a profound effect on the acidity of the hydroxyl proton?

Both the carboxylic acid and its conjugate base, the carboxylate anion, are stabilized by having additional resonance structures that delocalize electron densities. However, the stabilization in carboxylate anion is much greater because the two major resonance structures have equal contributions to the resonance hybrid, and the excess electron (negative charge) is shared equally between the two highly-electronegative oxygen atoms. This stabilization of the conjugate base leads to a markedly increased acidity of carboxylic acids.

Figure: Carboxylate Resonance Stabilization. Greater resonance stabilization of carboxylate anion compared to carboxylic acid results in increased acid strength. Click on each “i” for more information.

The Ka values of several carboxylic acids at 25 °C are shown below.

Figure: Carboxylic Acids. Line drawings of select carboxylic acid molecules, along with their Ka values at 25 °C (in red) and their names, are shown.

Inductive Effect

Atoms (or groups of atoms) in a molecule that are not directly bonded to the acidic H can also influence the molecule’s acidity. They can do so via an inductive effect, that is, they induce a polarization in the distribution of electrons within the molecule. This can be seen by studying the structures in Figure: Carboxylic Acids above. More electronegative substituents (F, Cl, Br) near the -COOH carboxyl group act to increase the acidity of the carboxylic acid. For example, fluoroacetic acid, CH2FCOOH, is significantly more acidic than acetic acid, CH3COOH.

This inductive effect works in two ways: It stabilizes the anionic conjugate base by drawing electron density away from the negatively charged -COO group (it is another way for the excess electron to delocalize to more atoms within the molecule). It also polarizes and weakens the O-H bond in the -COOH group by drawing electron density away from this bond in the acid, thereby facilitating ionization of hydrogen as H+.

The magnitude of the inductive effect depends on the nature as well as the number of halogen substituents. For an example, consider several acetic acid derivatives:

CH3COOH CH2ClCOOH CH2FCOOH CHCl2COOH CCl3COOH CF3COOH
ΔrG° (kJ/mol, 25 °C) +27 +16 +15 +7.7 +4.4 +3.0
Ka (25 °C) 1.8 × 10−5 1.4 × 10−3 2.2 × 10−3 4.5 × 10−2 1.7 × 10−1 3.0 × 10−1

Fluorine, which is more electronegative than chlorine, causes a larger inductive effect as it draws away greater amount of electron density to itself. Having three halogens, as opposed to one or two, causes a larger inductive effect. Note that inductive effects can be quite significant. For instance, replacing the –CH3 group of acetic acid by a –CF3 group results in an almost 10,000-fold increase in acidity.

In another example, the acidity of hypohalous acids [HOX(aq) + H2O(ℓ) ⇌ OX(aq) + H3O+(aq)] varies by about three orders of magnitude due to the difference in electronegativity of the halogen atoms:

ΔrG° (kJ/mol, 25 °C) Ka (25 °C)
HOCl 6.8 × 10−8 7.2
HOBr 3 × 10−9 8.5
HOI 3 × 10−11 10.5

Oxoacids

The acidity of oxoacids, with the general formula HOXOn (with n = 0−3), depends strongly on the number of terminal oxygen atoms (oxygen atoms only bonded to the central atom X).

Because oxygen is the second most electronegative element, adding terminal oxygen atoms causes strong inductive effect, thereby increasing the strength of the acid. For example, the figure below shows how the H atom in the acids becomes steadily more δ+ (more blue) from HClO to HClO4, making it easier for the acid to lose the hydrogen as an H+ ion.

Figure: Oxoacids. The figure shows the relationship between the acid strengths of the oxoacids of chlorine and the electron density on H in the O–H unit. These electrostatic potential maps show how the electron density on H decreases (darker blue color) as the number of terminal oxygen atoms increases. Blue corresponds to low electron densities, whereas red corresponds to high electron densities. Source: Chlorine oxoacids Ka values from J. R. Bowser, Inorganic Chemistry (Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks-Cole, 1993).

Also important is the effect of resonance stabilization in the conjugate base. For example, in the chlorite anion (ClO2), the excess electron density is delocalized equally over both oxygen atoms, whereas in the hypochlorite ion (ClO), the negative charge is largely localized on a single oxygen atom:

As a result of resonance stabilization and inductive effect, HClO2 is more than 200,000 times more acidic than HClO.

If we consider a series of oxoacids, we see that H3PO4 is a weak acid (Ka = 7.2 × 10−3), H2SO4 is a very strong acid (Ka = 4.0 × 103), and HClO4 (Ka = 3 × 107) is one of the strongest acids known. This trend is explained by the number of terminal oxygen atoms, which increases steadily across from P to Cl, consistent with the observed increase in acidity. In addition, the electronegativity of the central atom also increases, which further enhances the inductive effect on top of those from the terminal oxygen(s).

Comments
Please use this form to report any inconsistencies, errors, or other things you would like to change about this page. We appreciate your comments. 🙂

License

Icon for the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License

Chemistry 109 Fall 2021 by John Moore, Jia Zhou, and Etienne Garand is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License, except where otherwise noted.